By:
Conor Martin
Kerry manager Jack O’Connor has once again voiced his frustration over the controversial rule that forces a player to hand the ball back to an opponent when a free is awarded against him.
The seasoned boss claims the rule is easily exploited and has the potential to decide crucial matches.
His concerns came into sharp focus on Sunday in Killarney, where Kerry narrowly held off a spirited Roscommon side.
The champions secured victory thanks to Tomás Kennedy, who delivered a dramatic fisted point over the crossbar as the final hooter sounded.
The score handed Kerry a hard-fought win, but it was far from straightforward.
Just minutes earlier, Roscommon appeared on the verge of pulling off a shock upset. Diarmuid Murtagh had successfully converted a two-point free, which followed a controversial forward move of 50 metres.
Referee Brendan Cawley ruled that Kerry’s Mike Breen had failed to return the ball properly after Roscommon was awarded the free at the halfway line.
The decision sparked debate and highlighted the fine margins that can swing games.
O’Connor’s criticism reflects a wider frustration in Gaelic football circles, where the “hand back” rule is increasingly seen as inconsistent and open to gamesmanship.
While Kerry celebrated their narrow win, the discussion over whether this regulation is fair or fair enough shows no sign of fading.
Jack O’Connor speaks out against controversial Gaelic football rule
Speaking to RTÉ Radio 1, O’Connor said: “I’ve always been against that rule about handing the ball back,
“The ball should be placed on the ground where the foul occurs. You have stuff going on, I know where a fella holds the ball out and someone slaps it out of his hand and it’s brought forward 50 yards.
“That could have decided the game today, that two-pointer that Murtagh kicked from the ensuing free. It’s just a rule that will have to be looked at.”
The most controversial and ultimately decisive use of the rule came in the dying moments of the Munster club final last year when St Finbarr’s were marched 50 metres for not returning the ball.
That decision handed Daingean Uí Chúis a lifeline, and Conor Geaney made it count, landing a two-point free to flip a one-point deficit into a one-point victory as time expired.
Confusion over rule must be cleared up
The Kerry boss believes any grey areas need to be stamped out, especially when certain games have a lot riding on the line: “Whatever about respect, if it’s deciding big games, there’s just too much at stake to have such a grey area.
“If a fella holds the ball out and someone runs into him and the ball spills or slaps the ball out of his hand, how the hell is that his fault?
“I’ve been consistent on this one. I’ve said from the beginning that’s a rule that’s going to cause a lot of bother.
“Right throughout the club season, it caused bother. Big games decided on it. I certainly think that rule is going to have to be looked at.”
Categories
- Athletics (5)
- Aussie Rules (1)
- Basketball (12)
- Camogie (3)
- College American football (1)
- Combat (185)
- Cricket (17)
- Cycling (4)
- Darts (36)
- Editors-picks (13)
- Football (1210)
- Formula-1 (14)
- GAA (308)
- Golf (162)
- Hockey (1)
- Horse Racing (172)
- interviews (3)
- LGFA (3)
- MLB Baseball (2)
- NFL (23)
- ROI Radar (1)
- Rowing (1)
- Rugby (188)
- Snooker (6)
- Swimming (3)
- Tennis (17)
- Uncategorized (17)
- WWE (1)
