Home Rugby All Blacks 57 – 0 South Africa: Player Ratings After Hammering In Auckland

All Blacks 57 – 0 South Africa: Player Ratings After Hammering In Auckland

An eight-try All Black masterclass smashed records against South Africa and virtually secured the Rugby Championship for 2017.

So who glittered brightest among the stars in the 57-0 thrashing on the North Shore?

All Blacks

15 Damian McKenzie 7

A nervy beginning under the high ball but gradually grew into the game. Superb touch-finder in the second half and lots of elusive running cutting back from the right wing.

Starting to look much more comfortable at Test level.


14 Nehe Milner-Scudder 9

Showed why he is one of the great entertainers in world rugby.

Exceptional reading of the game, magical skills and a brace of tries as his reward.


13 Ryan Crotty 7

Solid defensively and took care of the dangerous Kriel.


12 Sonny Bill Williams 6.5

Quite quiet in the first half but solid performance from Williams.


11 Rieko Ioane 9

Is he the best winger in the world now? A monstrous 171 metres gained and eleven defenders beaten as he caused nightmares for opposite Raymond Rhule.

Pace to burn, power, anticipation and sensible decision-making – and remember he’s only 20.


10 Beauden Barrett 9

Absolutely sensational first half to bury his critics. Almost perfect place-kicking, excellent kicks in general play, an outrageous flick to set up Milner-Scudder for a sensational score.

And he did it again in the second half with a huge cross pass.


9 Aaron Smith 8.5

Another who was on fire in the first half. Set the tone for the All Black onslaught with a magnificent quick kick from a penalty to set up Ioane.

Slick passing, decision-making and defensive tidying-up. He sets the tempo for this side.


8 Kieran Read 7.5

Lots of classy small touches in the first half and was defensively excellent.

Super tackle in the second half to thwart Springbok drive to the line.


7 Sam Cane 7.5

Brilliant defensively, winning important turnovers with the Springboks threatening.


6 Liam Squire 7.5

Excellent physicality early in the first half before being subbed off with a head injury.


5 Sam Whitelock  7

Not sighted much with ball in hand but important lineout wins and tackles and caused problems for the Springboks.


4 Brodie Retallick 8

Won his battle with Eben Etzebeth and scored a storming try in the first half after a searing Ioane break.

Big presence all match.


3 Nepo Laulala  7

The front row got monstered in the early scrums in the first half but the inexperienced three righted the ship as the game wore on.


2 Dane Cole 8

Coles is another who was back to his best. Bustling skillful contributions and link play.

1 Kane Hames 6

Strong tackling but a few errors as he didn’t really show he is up to international class.

Subs: Scott Barrett 7.5; TJ Perenara 7.5; Ardie Savea 7; Wyatt Crockett 7; Ofa Tu’ungafasi 8; Codie Taylor 8.5; Lima Sopoaga 8; Anton Lienert Brown 8.5


South Africa

15 Andries Coetzee 6

Ran hard from the back but never really sped clear of the black wave.


14 Raymond Rhule 2

About as defensively sound as a sieve on the right wing missing a jaw-dropping nine tackles and barely sighted in the attack.


13 Jesse Kriel 5

Solid tackling but conceded a few turnovers and no penetration or inspiration on attack.


12 Jan Serfontein 6

Another to miss a few tackles but at least tried to bust the line and try to spark his ailing side.


11 Courtnall Skosan 4

Caught and marked a few kicks.

Few chances to show his afterburners but didn’t really go looking for opportunities either.


10 Elton Jantjies 4

A poor tactical showing from kickoffs and the overplayed the up and under.

A few darts to the line without ever threatening. Completely outplayed by his opposite number.


9 Francois Hougaard 5

Battled hard and strong defensively but not able to influence the game in the same way as Barrett did for the All Blacks.


8 Uzair Cassiem 6

Kept his motor running deep into the game leading the side with ten carries. Didn’t disgrace himself.


7 Jean-Luc Du Preez 4.5

Fairly anonymous throughout the game.


6 Siya Kolisi  5

A few strong runs but not dominant enough in the tackle to stop the All Blacks quick cleanouts.


5 Franco Mostert 4.5

Part of a shaky Springbok lineout and not much penetration ball in hand.


4 Eben Etzebeth 5.5

Leading tackler for the Boks but little of his aggressive presence with ball in hand.

Will be furious with the lineout mistakes.


3 Ruan Dreyer 5

Made a strong scrummaging start but barely sighted after that.


2 Malcolm Marx 5

A few typically blockbusting runs in the first half but serious lineout throwing wobbles seemed to affect his confidence.

1 Tendai Mtawarira 6

Very strong beginning with dominant scrummaging and strong early runs. Gradually got enveloped by the All Black wave after that.

Subs: Pieter-Steph DuToit 5.5, Trevor Nyakane 5, Others N/A.

Join The Biggest Rugby Club in Ireland

The Heineken Rugby Club is bringing Ireland together over cold beers and big games. No matter which team you back, we’re all friends here. Become a member for access to match tickets, member discounts and rewards, exclusive events, and much more.
  • I agree to Heineken Rugby Club House Rules and Privacy Policy. Over 18's only.

About The PA Team

This article was written by a member of The PA Team. If you would like to join the team, drop us an email at write@punditarena.com.