Close sidebar

Daily Discussion: Should Manchester United Really Sack Jose Mourinho?

Manchester United manager Jose Mourinho is fighting to save his job just three games into the new Premier League season after back-to-back defeats against Brighton and Tottenham.

Spurs’ 3-0 win at Old Trafford on Monday was the heaviest home defeat of his coaching career and the team looked a long way from being realistic title challengers.

So should Manchester United bite the bullet and fire the Portuguese coach or give Mourinho time to try to turn things around?

We look at the pros and cons of keeping him in charge.


_____

Third-season Syndrome

Now in his third season at Old Trafford, Manchester United might have already seen the best Mourinho has to offer.

In two spells at Chelsea and at Porto, Inter Milan and Real Madrid he always won the league in his second campaign. However, his third seasons at Chelsea and Madrid ended acrimoniously.

Mourinho won the League Cup and Europa League in his first season at United and finished second in the Premier League last season — albeit a record 19 points behind Manchester City.

But there is little evidence from an illustrious career of an ability to turn things around once the going gets tough.
_____

In-Team Friction

Mourinho’s relationship with key players appears fractured. There have been high-profile tensions with World Cup star Paul Pogba and his French compatriot Anthony Martial.

The Portuguese has always been a results-driven manager, able to point to a trophy-laden CV, and not feeling an overriding responsibility to enthral his fan base with entertaining football.

That approach caused friction at United even when results were positive in his first two seasons as it did not fit with the attacking traditions of the club under Alex Ferguson and Matt Busby.

Across town, Pep Guardiola has served up some spectacular football at Manchester City and Jurgen Klopp has produced a thrilling attacking side at Liverpool.

But the more prosaic Mourinho now does not even have results to fall back on.

United already trail Liverpool, Spurs and Chelsea by six points and City by four. Unless swift action is taken they risk missing out on the top four and the Champions League next season, while a title challenge already looks unlikely.
_____

Rot Predates Mourinho

Mourinho is not the only figure to blame at Old Trafford, where the team have not won the Premier League since Ferguson’s last season in 2012-13.

Last season’s second-place finish was United’s highest league position in the past five years and many of the club’s fans have laid the blame for the relative under-achievement at the door of executive vice-chairman Ed Woodward.

Fans were hoping the team could push on and mount a serious challenge to City but Woodward did not deliver the centre-back Mourinho wanted in the transfer window despite booming revenues.

Woodward handed Mourinho a new contract until 2020 as recently as January and oversaw the failed reigns of David Moyes and Louis van Gaal before the Portuguese arrived.

“Woodward gave him a contract last season, only seven or eight months ago, and he should see that contract through to the end and do the job,” said former United captain Gary Neville.

But luck does not appear to be on the manager’s side.

Mourinho summoned a positive response to the team’s defeat at Brighton during a dominant first-half display against Spurs that saw Romelu Lukaku miss a gilt-edged chance before the visitors took control after the break.

_____

Conclusion

If the club opts to dispense with Mourinho’s services there is not an abundance of candidates to take his place – with top managers Pep Guardiola and Mauricio Pochettino all tied up elsewhere. Zinedine Zidane is the only real candidate available with the necessary star power to quell the discontent of the Stretford End.

As Mourinho defiantly said himself, he has more Premier League titles than the other 19 managers in England’s top flight put together. On this basis, The Special One definitely deserves an opportunity to turn things around at Old Trafford and prove he’s still got what it takes to compete at the top.
_____

kca/jw/dmc

Author: The PA Team

This article was written by a member of The PA Team.